Nuclear Liability

Senate Roll Call Vote 475

1988 Scorecard Vote

Pro-environment vote

No

Votes For

53

Votes Against

41

Not Voting

6

The Price-Anderson Act was first passed in 1957. It was intended as a temporary, ten-year measure to encourage the development of the newly-formed nuclear power industry. It has been extended twice, and expired on August 1, 1987. The Act protects the utilities and their contractors from liability in the event of an accident: it is the only industry in the U.S. which does not have to pay full damages, including compensation for death, injury, and property damage caused by an accident (See House votes #6 and #7 for more on this issue).

The Metzenbaum (D-OH) amendment to the Price-Anderson Amendments (H.R. 1414) would make the companies that carry out the Department of Energy’s nuclear programs liable if an accident is caused by gross negligence or intentional misconduct. This amendment covered all aspects of the federal nuclear program, ranging from weapons production, research and testing, to radioactive waste transportation, storage, and disposal (Under the Price-Anderson Act, these companies are totally exempted from any accident liability).

The vote was on a Johnston (D-LA) motion to table the Metzenbaum amendment. The motion was agreed to by a vote of 53-41 on March 16, 1988. No is the pro-environmental vote.

Votes

Show Options
Show
Export data (CSV)
  • Pro-environment Vote
  • Anti-environment Vote
  • Missed Vote
  • Excused
  • Not Applicable

Vote Key

Sort by
Alabama
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

Alaska
1988 Scorecard Average

9%

Arizona
1988 Scorecard Average

88%

Arkansas
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

California
1988 Scorecard Average

92%

Colorado
1988 Scorecard Average

94%

Connecticut
1988 Scorecard Average

100%

Delaware
1988 Scorecard Average

94%

Florida
1988 Scorecard Average

0%

Georgia
1988 Scorecard Average

97%

Hawaii
1988 Scorecard Average

97%

Idaho
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

Illinois
1988 Scorecard Average

94%

Indiana
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

Iowa
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

Kansas
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

Kentucky
1988 Scorecard Average

9%

Louisiana
1988 Scorecard Average

9%

Maine
1988 Scorecard Average

47%

Maryland
1988 Scorecard Average

100%

Massachusetts
1988 Scorecard Average

100%

Michigan
1988 Scorecard Average

94%

Minnesota
1988 Scorecard Average

97%

Mississippi
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

Missouri
1988 Scorecard Average

0%

Montana
1988 Scorecard Average

41%

Nebraska
1988 Scorecard Average

3%

Nevada
1988 Scorecard Average

94%

New Hampshire
1988 Scorecard Average

88%

New Jersey
1988 Scorecard Average

100%

New Mexico
1988 Scorecard Average

100%

New York
1988 Scorecard Average

97%

North Carolina
1988 Scorecard Average

3%

North Dakota
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

Ohio
1988 Scorecard Average

44%

Oklahoma
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

Oregon
1988 Scorecard Average

100%

Pennsylvania
1988 Scorecard Average

90%

Rhode Island
1988 Scorecard Average

97%

South Carolina
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

South Dakota
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

Tennessee
1988 Scorecard Average

3%

Texas
1988 Scorecard Average

6%

Utah
1988 Scorecard Average

9%

Vermont
1988 Scorecard Average

97%

Virginia
1988 Scorecard Average

100%

Washington
1988 Scorecard Average

97%

West Virginia
1988 Scorecard Average

16%

Wisconsin
1988 Scorecard Average

50%

Wyoming
1988 Scorecard Average

3%